(*Note, I comprised this list of where they would be born and raised from, not where they would be most suited as a free choosing adult. That is another list - coming soon as additions are being made. 😊 PS: If this post sounds familiar, it's because it used to just include the Princesses but I decided to add the other Disney females to the list!)
For the sake of organization, I have chosen to divide the characters by "regions", which include: Pacific, Rocky Mountain, Southwest/Desert, Midwest, Northeast & Southeast (there are pictures to show which specific states are included in these regions.)
Tiger Lily: Santa Fe, New Mexico
"Venture into the unspoiled beauty of 7,000-foot Rocky Mountain vistas, marvel at the contrast of ancient native culture mixed with modern arts, feast on legendary cuisine and relax in rustic sophistication." Very similar to Tiger Lily's village on Neverland (modernized version).
Tinkerbell: Las Vegas, Nevada
"Las Vegas, in Nevada’s Mojave Desert, is a resort city famed for its vibrant nightlife, centered around 24-hour casinos and other entertainment options." Just like Neverland, it's a place for "all fun, all of the time" - and also like Neverland, there's not a lot of responsibility and/or parenting going on.
Jasmine: Tuscon, Arizona
"Tuscon has many... vintage shops, nightclubs and restaurants..." Tuscon is a cultured city in the middle of the desert, just like Agrabah. Most people there are still pretty conservative overall, but the youth tend to be a little more on the moderate or even progressive side - also similar to Agrabah.
Shanti: Athens, Ohio
Athens is a small town, located along the Hocking River (just like Shanti's village). While they don't have a ton of culture to offer, they do have an annual Halloween block party - a great place to tell stories like Mowgli's at the beginning of Jungle Book 2!
Eilonwy: Rapid City/Black Hills, South Dakota
"To the east lie the mysterious Badlands; to the north stands Devils Tower; turn south to Wind or Jewel Cave National Parks, Custer State Park, or Crazy Horse Mountain carving now in progress; or head 23 miles to majestic Mount Rushmore." All of these nearby locations fit with the various locations in the Black Cauldron: Pyrdain, the Horned King's Castle, the kingdom of the Fair Folk (fairies), the Marshes of Morva, etc.
Belle: Cody, Nebraska
A very small village, pretty much in the middle of nowhere, with little to offer beyond camping, farming or natural views. Sounds a lot like the place Belle comes from, showing why she had such a desire to see the world beyond this small place.
Ting-Ting, Mei & Su: Indianapolis, Indiana
Indianapolis is a mainly conservative place - just like where these princesses were raised. From the largest single-day sporting event in the world to the largest children’s museum in the world, it's easy to see that Indianapolis' culture thrives on being tough and family-oriented, responsible and dutiful. This perfectly matches these princesses and the way they were raised as well.